How Do I Know if My Teenager Needs Therapy?
As a parent, you don't want to overreact to normal teenage behavior, but you don't want to overlook something important either. Of course, teenagers can be moody, withdrawn, and stressed. This is normal. But when is it not normal? When is it something deeper that needs to be addressed?
The problem is that this is not always clear, cut, and dry. There may be certain things that are more obvious. For example, if it’s a panic attack or severe eating disorder, then it’s going to be much more noticeable.
But if it’s something more subtle, how do you know if your teenager needs therapy?
In this article, I go over 5 criteria that I hope will serve as a helpful guide and framework.
These are 5 "D" words to make things easier: 1) Discrepancy, 2) Distress, 3) Dysfunction, 4) Direct Self Report, and 5) Duration.
The 5 D Criteria:
Discrepancy – Has there been any meaningful, observable change in their behavior?
As a parent, you're often in a unique position to notice when something about your teen seems different: changes in their sleep, appetite, energy, motivation, etc. And evolving interests, moods, hobbies, and even identity is part of the maturation process.
So, while a break in their usual pattern may not indicate anything more to explore, when coupled with other observations (i.e. distress, dysfunction, duration, etc.), it may be an important clue that your teen could use support.
Distress – How much are they suffering?
All teenagers experience uncomfortable emotions: stress, sadness, frustration, anxiety, and disappointment are normal parts of life. This doesn't necessarily mean that therapy is required. However, while we all go through uncomfortable or negative emotions, the intensity, frequency, and persistent nature of these emotions can be helpful indicators that something more is going on.
Some questions to consider: Do their fears and worries turn into overwhelm? Do they recover from disappointment, or does it lead to shut down? Do their struggles recur repeatedly or on a loop even if things are going well?
Dysfunction – Is this affecting everyday living?
Next, is this interfering with things like school, sleep, extracurricular activities, friendships, family life, or hobbies? Because distress alone is not necessarily the deciding verdict, but it may be concerning when an emotional struggle is interfering with daily life. Whether you notice their grades slipping, friendships deteriorating, sleep patterns changing, or simply that they are disengaged from life, these changes can be important clues that your teen may be struggling and need some extra support.
Direct Self Report – Are they telling you that they need help or that they are struggling?
This one may be obvious, but the field of psychology is often based on self-report. A high-functioning depressive patient may be, on all accounts, seem to be doing well on the outside and mimicking the behaviors of a contributing member of society; and yet, inwardly, they are suffering. (This may seem to contradict the previous criteria of dysfunction, but keep in mind that people are complex and assessing someone's psychology is not a math equation.)
It's also possible that your teen may not always feel comfortable expressing how they feel or don't have the vocabulary or self-awareness to articulate their issues. That's why it's important to take self-report or no self-report in conjunction with the other criteria.
Duration – How long has this been going on?
An isolated incident isn't reason for alarm; patterns, however, tell a different story. Having a difficult day is one thing, but feeling anxious, withdrawn, or unusually irritable for several weeks could be cause for concern. The question to ask: Is the problem persisting, recurring, or worsening?
However, you don't need to wait a certain number of weeks or months before seeking help. For example, clinical depression requires symptoms to persist for at least 2 weeks. To reiterate, duration (or any one of these factors) is just one piece of the bigger picture.
You Don't Have to Check Every Box:
The five D's are intended to serve as a helpful guide, not a diagnostic checklist. Your teen doesn't need to meet all five criteria to benefit from therapy, and sometimes even one significant concern may be enough to warrant additional support. Every teenager is different, and emotional struggles can manifest in different ways.
If you're concerned that your teen—or someone you love—might benefit from therapy, we invite you to contact us for a free consultation. We're happy to answer your questions, discuss your concerns, and help you explore whether therapy might be a good fit.